Two quotes for the same 3D dinosaur EVA bath puzzle can sit well apart on a per-unit basis and still land at almost the same delivered cost — or the reverse. The quote that looks cheaper often becomes the more expensive one once you price the tooling, the packaging change, the freight and the rejects. This guide walks through the line items to collect from both suppliers, how to put them into one comparable landed-cost sheet, and which differences are worth paying for when the product is a children's bath toy.
The first mistake in a two-supplier comparison is comparing quotes that describe different items. Before you send anything out, write one specification sheet and attach it to both requests. For a 3D dinosaur EVA bath puzzle playset, the details that move price are usually these:
Send the same sheet to both suppliers and ask each one to confirm in writing what they can and cannot do. A supplier who quietly drops a requirement — double-sided lamination, a foldable carton, a specific ink — is not cheaper, they are quoting something else.
Landed cost is everything you pay before the goods reach your warehouse or your customer's doorstep. For an imported order from China, the sheet normally has these rows:
| Cost element | What to ask each supplier for |
|---|---|
| Unit price at your quantity | Price break at your target quantity and at one or two higher quantities, with the Incoterm stated (EXW, FOB, DDP) |
| Tooling and plates | Cutting die or mould cost, print plate cost per colour or per design, whether these are one-time or recurring |
| Samples | Sample fee, sample lead time, and who pays the courier |
| Packaging | What is included in the quoted price, and the surcharge for each packaging option you are considering |
| Inbound freight to port | Domestic trucking to the loading port if the quote is FOB |
| Ocean or air freight | Your own forwarder's rate for the carton count and total volume each supplier gives you |
| Insurance | Cargo insurance on the shipment value |
| Duty and import fees | Tariff classification, duty rate, brokerage and port handling at destination |
| Inspection and testing | Third-party inspection fee, and lab testing for the toy safety standard your market applies |
| Payment terms | Deposit percentage and when the balance falls due — this is a cash-flow cost, not just a number |
Build one spreadsheet with two columns — Supplier A and Supplier B — and use the same rows for both. Then work down:
Tooling and print plates are charged once, so their impact per unit depends entirely on how many units you order. A supplier quoting a lower unit price but higher tooling can still win on a large order and lose badly on a small one. Run the same sheet at your target quantity and at roughly double that quantity; where the two columns cross over is the volume at which the cheaper unit price actually starts to pay.
Foam sets ship light but bulky, and packaging is where quotes diverge most. A flat OPP bag, a header-card hanging pack and a folding retail box each change the unit price, the carton count and the shipment volume at once. Get the surcharge for every option from both suppliers and re-run the freight row for each. If one supplier offers foldable construction or foldable packaging, that is a freight saving you should convert into dollars per unit rather than leave as a bullet point.
The cheapest quote usually saves money by tightening tolerance on rejects. Add a row for the cost of defects: inspection fees, replacement units, and the freight to move replacements. A supplier that supports 100% third-party inspection, runs production tests such as colour fastness, tensile strength and children's product safety testing, and does full manual inspection before shipment is asking you to pay an inspection fee — and reducing the line above it. For a bath toy that a toddler puts in their mouth, a printed batch that fails a safety test is not a discount, it is a total loss.
Once both columns are complete, compare the two quotes on four questions rather than one number:
A useful habit is to write the gap between the two quotes as a percentage of landed cost rather than as a dollar figure. If Supplier A comes in a few percent cheaper on landed cost but charges more for tooling, needs a longer lead time and will not support an audit, that small saving disappears on the first reorder or the first delayed container.
Keep the finished sheet. The same comparison works next season with a different SKU, and your second round of supplier negotiation is far faster when you already know which rows moved last time.
Before you sign either quote, ask each supplier for a pre-production sample of the exact puzzle you specified — same foam, same print method, same piece count — and check the standing joints, the print registration and how the pieces behave after repeated wetting and drying. Print quality on foam is where two factories that look identical on paper diverge most in person.
For children's bath toys, compliance is part of cost, not a bonus. Ask each supplier which certificates and test reports they hold for the product and the destination market, and request copies rather than a list. The custom EVA foam manufacturing page on this site states ISO 9001:2015 certification and lists CE, EN-71, FDA, FCC, RoHS, SGS and REACH; confirm which of these applies to your specific set and country before you rely on it in your own listing or packaging.
Then check the process behind the number. The custom EVA product order process published on this site runs through requirements consultation, proposal and quotation, design drafts and renderings, mould or plate making, signed approval, and a 30% deposit on contract signature. Sample plates are quoted at 5–7 working days, and the bath puzzle product page quotes bulk production at 25–30 days after sample confirmation. Confirm which figure applies to your quantity and artwork in writing before you build a delivery date around it.
If you are sourcing a full toy range rather than one SKU, ask about combined shipments across categories such as wholesale EVA educational toys and adjacent sets like the 36-piece foam bath letters and numbers. Consolidating several SKUs into one container lowers freight per unit and often removes the difference between two suppliers entirely.
Send both quotes to a factory that will read them with you. Shenzhen Fulikai Packaging Products Co., Ltd. is a Shenzhen EVA foam products manufacturer working with custom orders since 2008, exporting to Japan, South Korea, Europe and the United States, and produces bath puzzles to customer drawings or samples with stamping, laser cutting and heat-transfer printing. Share your specification sheet and the two quotes, and the team can confirm which line items are real cost and which are padding.
Sales hotline: +86 13827489472 · Email: sales@fulikaisz.com.cn · Contact Fulikai
Tel
+86 13827489472
+86 13827489472
sales@fulikaisz.com.cn
5th Floor, Building B, Yuanfen Industrial Zone, Dalang Street, Longhua District, Shenzhen, China